shoppable

20 Unique And Personal Mother’s Day Gifts For First-Time Moms

by Olivia Jakiel
Olivia Jakiel is an experienced editor and writer residing in the magical and enchanting land of North Hollywood, CA. She enjoys baking, cooking, and long walks to the wine cellar with her dog, and also consumes rotisserie chicken at an extremely alarming rate. Bylines on HelloGiggles, MSN, Yahoo, Obsev, and more.

Mother’s Day is one of the most important and special holidays of the year! After all, would any of us even be here if it weren’t for all the amazing moms in this world?

Think about it — we sure wouldn’t! Moms literally gave us life, and for that, there are never enough ways to say thank you.

And while every mom on this planet will tell you that every Mother’s Day is just as special as the previous one, there is nothing quite like celebrating one’s very first Mother’s Day! Whether it’s your first Mother’s Day celebrating with your brand-new bundle of joy or you’re celebrating as an expectant mama-to-be, these 20 items from Etsy are the perfect way to get yourself a little something for your special day — or to pass along to your partner and loved ones for a “surprise” this holiday.

Scroll through these 20 gift ideas to find the perfect one!

1. Wine Glass, $9.99

1. Wine Glass, $9.99

Every mom needs a dedicated wine glass for those nights (or afternoons — hey, we don’t judge!) where you just need to relax. This is also the perfect way to tell a brand-new mama, “Welcome to the club.”

Buy it on Etsy for $9.99.

2. "Mama Bear" Poem, $20.90

2. "Mama Bear" Poem, $20.90

This “Mama Bear” print is both sweet and fierce, and it will remind the mama bear in your life how strong she is!

Buy it on Etsy for $20.90.

3. Cross-Stitch Heart, $19.20

3. Cross-Stitch Heart, $19.20

Cross-stitching is SO in this year. Stay on trend and granny-chic with this cute and homey cross-stitch heart!

Buy it on Etsy for $19.20.

4. Mother-Daughter Jewelry Set, $59.50

4. Mother-Daughter Jewelry Set, $59.50

Call it a mommy-and-me first jewelry set, call it adorable as a baby, call it whatever you want — this matching necklace set perfectly represents the unbreakable bond mothers and daughters share with one another.

Buy it on Etsy for $59.50.

5. Gift Box, $40.50

5. Gift Box, $40.50

Who doesn’t love a box full of gifts — especially one that caters to moms!

Buy it on Etsy for $40.50.

6. Customized Picture Frame, $22.91

6. Customized Picture Frame, $22.91

A personalized picture frame commemorating one’s first Mother’s Day is the sweetest way to do so! You can even take a picture of you and your little bundle of joy on the big day so you can relive that memory for years and years to come.

Buy it on Etsy for $22.91.

7. Baby Feet Keychain, $12.98

7. Baby Feet Keychain, $12.98

This tiny baby feet keychain is the sweetest way to remind someone of the most important job they’ll ever have during their life every time they get their keys out!

Buy it on Etsy for $12.98.

8. Personalized Ornament, $3.77

8. Personalized Ornament, $3.77

This personalized ceramic Mother’s Day plaque can serve as a Christmas ornament or as a sweet daily reminder on your nightstand (or wherever!).

Buy it on Etsy for $3.77.

9. Tacos for Two Sweater, $23

9. Tacos for Two Sweater, $23

Pregnancy cravings can be serious… seriously delicious! But really, who doesn’t want tacos (while pregnant or, like, all the time)? This cute and comfy sweater is perfect for the expecting mama in your life!

Buy it on Etsy for $23.

10. Customized Beer Bottle Labels, $12

10. Customized Beer Bottle Labels, $12

Contrary to popular belief, not all moms love to sip on wine! Some people prefer their “mommy juice” to be something a little hoppier, like beer. These customized labels are the perfect way to designate an emergency supply of “mommy juice” for specific situations!

Buy them on Etsy for $12.

11. First Mother's Day Mug, $18.30

11. First Mother's Day Mug, $18.30

How else would you get your fuel for the day? This simple but chic “Happy 1st Mother’s Day” mug will remind you of your first Mother’s Day every time you sip from it.

Buy it on Etsy for $18.30.

12. Customized Spoon, $8.78

12. Customized Spoon, $8.78

Hear me out — customized spoons are going to be the next big trend! It’s a sweet and slightly quirky memento that every mom and mom-to-be will absolutely adore!

Buy it on Etsy for $8.98.

13. Star Map, $10.50

13. Star Map, $10.50

This customized star map is truly out of this world!

Buy it on Etsy for $10.50.

14. Mother's Day Candle, $12

14. Mother's Day Candle, $12

If you’re a mom and you don’t like candles, are you really even a mom at all? Seriously, I’ve never met a mom who loathes candles, so this one commemorating the first Mother’s Day of many will surely put a smile on a new mom’s face.

Buy it on Etsy for $12.

15. Mom AF Tee, $20.99

15. Mom AF Tee, $20.99

If you need a gift for the new millennial mom in your life, look no further. She’ll most definitely think you’re cool AF (as the youths say).

Buy it on Etsy for $20.99.

16. Funny Card, $4.49

16. Funny Card, $4.49

If you know a new mom with a great sense of humor, this card is perfect to give her for her first Mother’s Day.

Buy it on Etsy for $4.49.

17. Mom Ring Dish, $10

17. Mom Ring Dish, $10

Every mom needs a safe spot to keep her jewelry, and this ring dish is a cute way to do so!

Buy it on Etsy for $10.

18. New Mama Gift Basket, $56.25

18. New Mama Gift Basket, $56.25

No one ever gets mad about a gift basket — it’s like 10 gifts in one! This one caters specifically to new and soon-to-be moms.

Buy it on Etsy for $56.25.

19. New Mommy Mug, $11.95

19. New Mommy Mug, $11.95

How sweet is this floral mug for the newly minted mommy?

Buy it on Etsy for $11.95.

20. Baby Diary, $23.99

20. Baby Diary, $23.99

A new baby journal is quite the special gift! Bonus: One day you can give it to your children and they can read about the magical time after they were born!

Buy it on Etsy for $23.99.

Psst: If you choose to purchase an item on this list, LittleThings may receive a small cut. Each item and price is up to date at the time of publication; however, an item may be sold out or the price may be different at a later date.